Every anniversary tells a chapter of your love story. Here's a guide to traditional and modern anniversary gifts—with jewelry suggestions for each milestone. Year-by-Year Guide 1st Anniversary — Paper (Traditional) / Clocks (Modern) Your first year together! A delicate pendant necklace or simple stud earrings make a beautiful, wearable keepsake to mark year one. 5th Anniversary — Wood (Traditional) / Silverware (Modern) Five years strong. Consider upgrading her wedding band with a diamond band or adding a stackable ring to...